SmarterSelect vs Givebutter

RQ Platform

Submittable

OpenWater

RQ Platform is an all-in-one Application and Review software platform for streamlining and simplifying your entire program, designed for Awards, Scholarships, Grants, Fellowships, Mentorships, Volunteer Recruitment and more.

Submittable provides grant management and corporate social responsibility software for foundations, governments, and corporations. The platform enables organizations to build customizable application forms, manage review processes, and track program budgets in real time without technical expertise. It includes features for fraud prevention, impact reporting, and automated workflows that help streamline administrative tasks.

OpenWater streamlines program management with its end-to-end solution for accepting and reviewing applications, awards, grants, scholarships, proposals, and abstracts.

Educational Grant Officer 

Only downside is the support system - which if you are not a tech person can be difficult to understand as you have to explain what your problem is in messages.

Make better decisions faster. Streamline how you choose the best candidates for your scholarship, grant, and award programs.

Sized perfectly for one program – or one thousand! Designed for non-technical users, no coding required. Set up your programs yourself, often in less than one day.

Activity Tracking

Alerts/Notifications

Applicant Portal

Applicant Tracking

Application Management

Audit Management

Commenting/Notes

Communication Management

Compliance Management

Customizable Fields

Customizable Forms

Customizable Questions

Customizable Reports

Customizable Templates

Data Import/Export

Deadline Management

Document Review

Electronic Payments

Electronic Submission

Email Reminders

For Grantmakers

Forms Management

For Nonprofits

For Schools

Grant Application Management

Grant Award Tracking

Grant Management

Interview Management

Member Database

Multi-Currency

Preview Functionality

Progress Tracking

Ratings/Reviews

Recommendations

Reminders

Reporting & Statistics

Reviewer Management

Role-Based Permissions

Scoring

Search/Filter

Single Sign On

SSL Security

Status Tracking

Third-Party Integrations

Web Forms

White Label

Most users consider SmarterSelect a great value due to its affordability and stable pricing, and they appreciate added features without extra cost. Some users report that entry-level plans lack features and higher tiers are costly for small groups.

Value for money

By industry, SmarterSelect reviewers are most commonly professionals in non-profit organization management (49%). The most frequent use case cited by reviewers is scholarship management (69%).

SmarterSelect

Web-based

Instrumentl

Basic

Executive Director

SmarterSelect allows us to manage and process over 800 applications annually.   When we made the decision to migrate over to Smarter Select, we found that we spend muck less time in the management process, which allowed us to spend more time fundraising and working with recipients and donors.

The fact that the body of an email (personal message box) will not let you put in an email address different to what is outside of the letter, and if you put one in and press send it then makes the email disappear and then you have to re write it.

It has allowed us to streamline our processes and move from paper applications to one simple common online application for scholarships.

Office Manager/Program Assistant

Also, the very tiny save button at the bottom of the grant applications and final reports gets missed and the information is not saved which is frustrating for the grantees because they have to start over.

Auxiliary National Secretary 

We found some things like we need to have a person view each application since the applicant could download anything and shows it is complete when they are missing information still.

Counselor

I don't like the tiers you need to buy just to add the Spanish language. When everything in our education system is setup to support Spanish speakers it seems lame a program that cost so much cannot support Spanish speakers unless we upgrade.

Sr. HR Specialist

In my experience, in order to send reminders to those on "incomplete" statuses and "pending" statues you have to go to two separate parts of the site.

Communications Manager

When I customize my Applications view, it doesn't "stick" - I have to re-customize it every single time I go back to it.

Office Manager

Also, we ask so many questions in our scholarship application that our calculations are sometimes slow that they don't always calculate without refreshing the calculations.

The only thing I wish we had (which is probably available on a higher tier), is the ability for scores to be added in the evaluator section for their viewing.

Director of Data & Evaluation

SmarterSelect has made it possible for our organization to grow our programs quickly by streamlining our application processes.

President-Elect

The software allowed us to move from a paper-based system to online applications for our scholarships.

Program Officer

SmarterSelect changing major components of the software during the critical time in our scholarship program without any notice or warning or any tutorials of what is going on.

Associate Commissioner

There are numerous capabilities within the platform which we are still learning as staff turns over or duties shift but we are quite pleased with the Smarter Select platform.

Operations Manager

Most of our board members review online, which is ideal, but for those that prefer a printed binder, the export design ends up costing me more time than it should.

It can be very time-consuming. When our reviewers (independent scholarship committee) go into do their part, we've found that the software sometimes will not hold their ratings even though they are saving as they go.

Workforce Development Manager

When using a program from the library and trying to customize is difficult and I don’t like that I had to delete sections and start over.

I enjoy the ability to customize the site easily, even for those without any sort of web-design knowledge.

I just want to make sure we are using what is available to us as changes to the software are made and our grandfathered price increases.

College Counselor/College Prep Instructor

I like that once familiar with Smarter Select, you're able to have the ease and stress-free experience of managing scholarships that are difficult to put in one place.

I like to be able to have a common application for scholarships and to customize the specific scholarships.  

I think anytime you pay an annual bill for SAS (software as service) you think about value and the wisdom of spending scarce resources.

I can customize the whole system to what I need it to do in order to fit Mt needs.

I think there may be a setting to send completed ones to the reviewers but they like getting them all but would prefer the program separate them rather than lump them all together.

scholarship/fellowship coordinator

Sometimes my institution's firewall blocks the reporting emails and it was slightly difficult to fix that this year.

Executive Assistant

I love that it is online and that users can have multiple roles, which is key in our small town and organization

executive director

Having the ability for applicants to apply online is critical to our operation and staying current and relevant.  

We worked with smarter select to customize the application as much as the platform currently allows.

Program Coordinator

With Smarter Select I can download and filter on any field to get to the information I need.

Program Specialist

Every once is awhile there is a bug that needs fixing, but Customer Service quickly identifies issues and fixes them without delay.

Foundation Coordinator

Secondly, the delete feature should be able to be canceled within a few seconds/minutes to avoid any permanent issues.

Donor Relations Coordinator

Small con:  I wish that when the button to disable an application is selected that the "active" button would uncheck.

We are able to begin and end our grants management procedures within the same system.

The support system is a bit hit and miss depending on how much technical knowledge you have and who you get replying to your enquiry.

We really like that we can open and close the scholarship process just by setting up the dates ahead of time.

Marketing Coordinator

Being an evaluator isn't as intuitive when viewing and printing the documents.  

Manager, Research and Innovation

Occasionally, since I am a user and administrator, I get an error indicating I am not allowed to access certain things.

It's ability to export in a format that our dozen's of reviewers can utilize has been appreciated.

Managing Director

I wish there was a way that I could make adjustments to the application once it has gone live. If there is a way, I don't know how to do it.

We love that the forms are customizable and are easy to set auto-calculation and autoscoring features.

I like the fact that all the information is in one place and we're not having to search different places for information.  

Scholarships Administrator

SmarterSelect has allowed us to receive less mailed in applications.  

Director of Development

Unable to search a single person across multiple grant applications.

Program Director

We are using SmarterSelect to select students for a leadership program.  

Development Director

Adding scoring or questions sometimes is less than intuitive when you first learn how to do it.

Foundation Director

I can usually find posts of similar issues when troubleshooting which is nice to resolve and move on.

Project Director

In addition, all of our reviewers are able to complete their assignments online at their convenience.

The major qualm I have with SmarterSelect is the export options.

Director

SmarterSelect helped us streamline our scholarship application process saving time and money!

Scholarship Management

Customization

Email Communication

Applicant Review

Data Export

Bugs and Issues

Process Management

File Upload and Download

Evaluator Access

Small Business

Mid-size Business

Large Enterprises

Freelancers

Most users consider SmarterSelect a great value, noting its affordability and flexibility for organizations of varying sizes. Reviewers indicate that pricing remains stable over time, with no dramatic increases, and appreciate that new features are added without significant cost hikes. Users think the platform offers comparable functionality to higher-priced alternatives, making it accessible for those with smaller budgets. Some users report that the entry-level plan could include more features, and a few feel that moving to higher tiers is costly for small groups. Reviewers appreciate the ease of use and overall cost-effectiveness.

Zeffy

Zeffy is the first and only zero-free fundraising platform. Sell tickets for your fundraising events, create donation and peer-to-peer campaigns, and manage donors and even memberships from an intuitive all-inclusive fundraising platform.

DonorPerfect

DonorPerfect helps nonprofits of every size streamline fundraising and centralize donor data in one flexible, all-in-one platform.
A CRM that empowers teams to collaborate, stay organized, and make data-driven decisions from anywhere, so your mission keeps moving forward.

Donorbox

Donorbox is an embeddable, localized donation form / plugin for websites, designed to encourage recurring donations with fast, multi-step checkout

Project Manager

Should a resource ever not be available, their customer service is some of the best I have ever seen, with a human being able to answer my questions within minutes.

The software is intuitive and robust and the best of all that is possible with Givebutter is the absolute world class customer service.

Givebutter is a cloud-based, all-in-one fundraising platform for student organizations, sports teams, companies, and nonprofits which offers a range of tools for collecting donations online, running social peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns, selling tickets to fundraising events, and more

SmarterSelect vs Givebutter Comparison (2026)

SmarterSelect

Givebutter

Overview

Video & Screenshots

Pricing

User reviews

Key features

Integrations

Alternatives