Greater Giving vs WinningBidder.com

Givebutter

Auctria

OneCause

Givebutter combines all-in-one fundraising software, 0% fees, and built-in rewards—so you can raise more, pay less, and multiply your impact with 2.5% APY on every dollar you raise.

Auctria: a budget friendly web solution to run your entire event from tickets to receipts; traditional auctions or online fundraisers.

OneCause has helped 14,000+ nonprofits raise more than $8 billion through 90,000+ fundraising events & campaigns. Our software helps manage all types of fundraising: events, auctions, appeals, raffles, peer-to-peer, online giving, tributes & memorials, giving days, and awareness campaigns. 

Development Director

A lot of guessing and calls to customer service.

Senior Development Officer

Greater giving has an amazing customer service team that is supportive and clear to work with.

Business Relations and operations

Staff has been wonderful and patient with our various questions.

Greater Giving works exclusively with registered 501c3 schools and nonprofits - offering integrated solutions to help simplify your auction gala or fundraising event, streamline check-in and check-out, stay organized and raise more funds.

Absentee Bidding

Access Controls/Permissions

Accounting

Activity Dashboard

Alerts/Notifications

Attendance Management

Attendee Management

Auction Management

Bid Management

Billing & Invoicing

Buy Now Option

Campaign Analytics

Campaign Management

Catalog Management

Committee Management

Contact Management

Contribution Tracking

Credit Card Processing

Customizable Branding

Customizable Fields

Customizable Forms

Customizable Reports

Dashboard

Data Import/Export

Donation Tracking

Donor Discovery

Donor Management

Electronic Payments

Email Management

Event Management

Event Scheduling

Event Ticketing

Event Tracking

For Nonprofits

Fundraising Management

Gift Matching Management

Goal Setting/Tracking

Image Library

Inventory Management

Live Auction

Member Database

Membership Management

Mobile Access

Mobile Alerts

Mobile Giving

Online Auction

Online Bidding

Online Forms

Online Giving

Payment Processing

Pledge Management

Proxy Bidding

Real-Time Notifications

Receipt Management

Recurring Giving

Recurring/Subscription Billing

Registration Management

Reporting/Analytics

Reporting & Statistics

Reverse Bidding

Search/Filter

Silent Auction

Social Media Integration

Volunteer Management

Watch List

Website Integration

Website Management

Greater Giving

iPhone

Android

Windows

iPad

Linux

Chromebook

Web-based

BiddingOwl.com

Silent Auction Pro

SchoolAuction.net

Basic

Benefits and Compliance Manager

Event management capabilities were apparent and data reports that can be generated after an event are useful.

Program and Operations Manager

I am used to being able to default to charging for credit card processing fees (giving the user the option to easily opt out).

Greater Giving is a great product for nonprofit auctions, has a smooth platform for auction guests, and as an easy ticketing system.

Event Specialist

Volunteers pick up on the program quickly, sometimes day of an event and it all around lifts so much stress.

Treasurer

In general, I like the system, but some things didn't go well for us (e.g., date of fundraiser event was incorrect, even though comms to GG about this were not acted upon, therefore credit card readers did not work - a disaster for check-in.).

PR and Communications Coordinator

There's a section for each feature I need, and there are lots of options if I need something specific for my event.

Co Founder and Treasurer

Excellent software, and great support from the helpdesk, who each time I speak to them they teach me something new I can use to make our event better.

It was also great for generating receipts and invoices.

Communications and Development Coordinator

We’ve used Greater Giving  for years for our various fundraisers and the best feature is being able to use the same features year after year especially with our sponsor levels and perks.

Administrative Assistant

It is just not very user-friendly changing some aspects of your published website, but otherwise there are not really any complaints.

Every time I needed help answering a question or figuring out a best practice, I always got everything answered completely.

Helpful & knowledgable with many years of experience specifically on this platform.

Finance Director

The sales/payment reporting function is cumbersome.

Having all of our constituents filed over the years makes the process of opening a new event easy and seamless.

Dir. of Advancement

I've been using Greater Giving for 10 years and have enjoyed using their auction software for ease of use and customer service.

Administrative Assistant/Development/Admissions

I love the capability to produce websites where tickets can be purchased and it can be used for so many different platform.

For one example, if you add a logo for a sponsor to add to the event landing page, it doesn't say that it has to be specific format.

The flexibility of the software can be very clunky and not so user friendly.

System is very intuitive but appreciated the best practices intro.

There are some Day of Auction Glitches, like logging people out of the system and screens freezing during bidding.

Development Manager

The lack of ability to have guests edit their purchase information and guest list info.

It provides easy to learn and use products for a variety of events.

I have used Greater Giving for years and specifically, appreciate the customer service.

Questions are answered in a timely fashion by knowledgeable representatives.

Ability to handle entire event through one site and organizing system.

Fundraising Coordinator

I would like to have the option to enter in an item number when adding items to packages, not just words.   When you have multiple people getting packages ready, not everyone uses the same wording and it is putsy and annoying to have to go out of Packages and into Items to find what I'm looking for if I don't use the same words that someone else used to identify an item.   If you are going to have us assign numbers, maximize that.  

Executive Director

I'm a visual person and figuring out this program all on my own, well, as an ED sometimes I just need you to tell me what to do and show me how to do it.

Event coordinator

It did not have some of the abilities our previous service had, which made a ton of extra work on our end.

Auction Consultant 

The only draw back is when a donor donates more than one of an item for an auction and it will be placed in multiple packages.

Event Chair Auction Manager

Our event is biennial and coming back 18 months later was much easier knowing the staff and help center were prepared to assist.

The cost of setup and annually can be a bit high but doesn't outweigh all the benefits.

Having the consistency & info between the years is really helpful as the volunteers change each year.  

Software is very well organized and not difficult to learn and manage; help chat is always there with a quick solution to your problem.

Philanthropy Specialist

We ran our first silent auction and fund-a-need using Greater Giving last November.  

Marketing Manager

We have been utilizing Greater Giving for our annual fundraising events.  

Marketing Coordinator

The help videos are an amazing tool if you get stuck trying to set things up.

Event organizer

Their customer service and technical support is helpful, but I shouldn’t have to call them as often as I do.

Text to donate  is what our organization utilizes the most.

We have had two events since last November, and both were very successful using Greater Giving as our platform!

Director of Community Engagement

It's user friendly and the donor-facing software is intuitive even for less confident users.

Elsewhere in the software, you have the capability to look up package numbers and item numbers.

The event software is extremely hard to use, and not intuitive unless you have lots of website experience.

Overall, it has been a very positive 10+ years working with Greater Giving. As the years have gone by it has become more and more value added.

I really appreciate the customer service Greater Giving provides.  

Everytime I called, I was able to make great progress in the system.

Clumsy, glitchy, counter-intuitive program.

Customer Support

User Interface

Ease of Use

Phone Support

Features

Setup

Training and Learning Curve

Small Business

Large Enterprises

Mid-size Business

Freelancers

Global Payments

Operations Manager

The fact that the staff is so willing to speak with you on the phone for as long as you need goes a long way in getting your project going smoothly.  

We loved the service - we will definitely use it again. When we had a problem, customer service fixed it right away.

WinningBidder.com provides low cost online auction software for nonprofits. Our software is simple to use, allowing organizers to launch an auction in minutes.

Real-Time Monitoring

By industry, WinningBidder.com reviewers are most commonly professionals in non-profit organization management (42%). The most frequent use case cited is auction (100% of reviewers).

Users and use cases

WinningBidder.com is an auction program with key features that include online bidding, online auctions, payment processing, bid management, and more.

WinningBidder.com

PHP Pro Bid

Bid Beacon

GiveSmart

Health and Outreach Manager

I also didn't like if we wanted to close out and then open back up for the things that didn't sell, we would have to start a brand new auction versus opening it back up.

Director of Operations

It made our ability to reach bidders from outside our event very simple as well.

Foundation Manager

Include a Save feature - when inputting auction items

president

there were no cons specifically, we did note the option to pay cash or check via donated items but automatically invoices so most people just paid with their card.

Donor Relations Coordinator

The printing poster feature was a little off - we had to re-create our own posters - the image was cropped funny on some of the posters.

President

User registration was also very smooth; we did not receive any complaints or have issues with attendees signing up and making bids.

volunteer

Luckily, we could see what the bidders won and allowed them to pay by cash, venmo or check to avoid fees.

Tournament Director

The site gave us the opportunity to manage the event up to closing when we saw a big increase in activity.  

Greater Giving vs WinningBidder.com Comparison (2026)

Greater Giving

WinningBidder.com

Overview

Video & Screenshots

Pricing

User reviews

Key features

Integrations

Alternatives