Samsara vs MyTrucking

Motive

One Step GPS

Elite EXTRA

Motive is a cloud-based fleet management solution that helps fleets of all types track vehicles with real-time GPS, automate operations, simplify compliance, and more, using a centralized platform.

One Step GPS is a web-based fleet tracking solution designed for businesses of all sizes across various industries such as construction, transportation, and service businesses that offers real-time fleet GPS tracking capabilities.  It allows users to monitor the location of their vehicles in real-time and offers vehicle visibility and safety. It helps businesses from asset theft.

Deliver faster, smarter, and more efficiently with Elite EXTRA. Our platform optimizes routing and dispatch, connects you to nationwide 3PL fleets, and automates returns for a seamless customer experience. Cut costs, boost speed, and delight customers with every delivery.

Fleet Manager

The customer service and reporting a problem through the system.   If I call my rep it's great customer service.   If I can't get in touch with him or I used the reporting on line it takes far to long to get help and resolution

Logistic Analyst

the best feature is the customer service/ support team that is always willing to help and follow up with tickets.

Samsara is a fleet operations management platform which helps businesses across various industries including transportation, logistics, and construction streamline fleet operations with features such as GPS fleet tracking, ELD compliance, routing and dispatch, documents, reporting and alerts, and more.

Access Controls/Permissions

Accounting

Activity Dashboard

Alerts/Notifications

Asset Tracking

Audit Trail

Barcoding/RFID

Carrier Management

Communication Management

Compliance Management

Customer Database

Customer Management

Customizable Forms

Customizable Reports

Data Visualization

Dispatch Management

Document Management

Drag & Drop

Driver Logs

Driver Management

Emergency Dispatch

Employee Management

Equipment Tracking

Fleet Management

For Drivers

For Freight Operations

For Schools

Fuel Cost Management

Fuel Management

Fuel Tracking

Geofencing

Geographic Maps

Geolocation

GIS Integration

Heatmaps

Historical Reporting

IFTA Reporting

Incident Reporting

K-12

Live Driver Tracking

Location Tracking

Maintenance Management

Maintenance Scheduling

Mileage Tracking

Mobile Access

Mobile App

Monitoring

Order Tracking

Performance Metrics

Quotes/Estimates

Real-Time Analytics

Real-Time Data

Real-Time Monitoring

Real-Time Notifications

Real-Time Updates

Records Management

Refund Management

Reminders

Repair Tracking

Reporting/Analytics

Reporting & Statistics

Route Management

Route Optimization

Routing

Safety Management

Scheduling

Search/Filter

Self Service Portal

Service History

Shipment Tracking

Shipping Management

Technician Management

Third-Party Integrations

Time Tracking

Transportation Management

Trend Analysis

Trip Logs

Truckload Management

Vehicle Information

Vehicle Maintenance

Vehicle Management

Vehicle Tracking

Video Capture

VIN Lookup

Violation Tracking

Work Order Management

By industry, Samsara reviewers are most commonly professionals in transportation/trucking/railroad (42%). The most frequent use case for Samsara cited by reviewers is fleet management (65% of reviewers).

Users and use cases

Some reviewers feel Samsara offers good value for money due to robust features, helpful upgrades, and flexible payment plans. However, users report high pricing, frequent increases, extra charges, and unclear information about upgrades and costs.

Value for money

Samsara is a GPS tracking tool with key features that include vehicle tracking, real-time monitoring, GPS functionality, compliance management, driver management, mobile access, and more.

Samsara

Web-based

iPhone

iPad

Android

Verizon Connect

Geotab

Omnitracs One

Azuga Fleet

DriveCam

Teletrac Navman DIRECTOR

Driver•i One

Fleetio

GPS Insight

Zonar 

Platform Science

Titan GPS

Basic

Restrictive and opaque contracts

Safety

The pricing structure is on the higher end of the market, and the long-term contract commitments (usually 3 years) can be intimidating for a small growing fleet.

Dispatch Manager

Keep in mind this company like many others will lock you into an additional contract period (3 more years)  at the end of your first one if you do not provide notice.

91% of reviewers feel negative about Contract Issues. Users think long-term contract commitments are inflexible and intimidating, especially for smaller fleets. Reviewers indicate that auto-renewal policies and hidden contract details make it difficult to exit agreements without incurring high fees. They say customer support is unhelpful when resolving contract disputes, and some feel misled by sales practices. Many users express frustration over being locked into contracts despite ongoing issues or dissatisfaction with the service.

Unreliable speed limit detection

Service Manager

Harsh Break, yet the truck never once decreased in speed. or Crash Alert, yet the vehicle is parked on the side of the street and the camera doesn't pick up any vehicles around and no damage witnessed.   or Speeding - Vehicle is on a 60 mph posted highway yet the system says they are on a 35 mph side street and incorrectly flag the truck  as speeding, deducting points from our team. or When we dismiss these events or try to inform the AI system that it is wrong  their is no proper indication that the points have been corrected and if our driver score been updated correctly.

60% of reviewers feel negative about Speed Monitoring. Reviewers report that speed limit data is often outdated or inaccurate, resulting in false speeding alerts and unfair driver penalties. Users say the system’s sensitivity settings are confusing, and speed-related notifications do not always reflect actual road conditions. They find it challenging to correct errors or update speed limits, and some mention that lag in data updates further complicates monitoring. Many users express frustration with the impact on driver safety scores and operational reporting.

Inconsistent and excessive alerts

Operations Manager

At times, many coaching alerts are generated that are barely actionable. If my team does not have logins or apps, scheduling behavior counseling is time-consuming.

Safety and compliance manager

Without proper setup, the system can generate excessive alerts that require manual filtering, which is time-consuming.

62% of reviewers feel negative about Alerts and Notifications. Users think alert systems are overly sensitive, generating too many notifications that are not always actionable or accurate. Reviewers indicate that real-time alerts can be delayed, missed, or difficult to customize, leading to wasted time reviewing irrelevant events. They say false or redundant alerts distract drivers and managers, and some users struggle to locate or filter specific notifications. Many users mention that critical alerts, such as accident notifications, sometimes fail to trigger.

Complicated and unreliable billing

President

I was very frustrated with this situation, but went ahead and let them draft the next 6 months of payments on my credit card which they have on file (Bad mistake to give them credit card authorization).    When they continued charging my charge card in August, September and beyond,  I called again to stop this.

84% of reviewers feel negative about Billing and Payment. Reviewers report frequent billing errors, double charges, and difficulty matching invoices to assets. Users say the cancellation process is unclear, with unexpected penalties and continued charges after service termination. They find customer service slow to resolve payment disputes and mention unauthorized withdrawals or challenges with refunds. Many users feel that features are removed or repackaged as paid add-ons, increasing costs unexpectedly.

Frequent technical glitches

65% of reviewers feel negative about Bugs and Issues. Users report recurring problems with app connectivity, data syncing delays, and slow system performance. Reviewers indicate that editing logs or reports can be cumbersome due to software bugs, and mobile app instability disrupts field operations. They say support response times for technical issues are slow, and some features appear rushed or inadequately tested. Many users mention frustration with glitches affecting daily workflow and compliance tasks.

Enhanced safety management

Samsara has helped us with our safety bonus program, safety scores and increase fuel economy across the fleet.

Solved all of my compliance and tracking concerns using Samsara.

93% of reviewers feel positive about Safety and Compliance. Users think the platform’s safety features, such as video event review, safety scoring, and AI-driven alerts, are vital for reducing incidents and promoting safe driving. Reviewers appreciate the tools for monitoring compliance, coaching drivers, and documenting events for insurance or training. They say the system helps build a safety-focused culture, supports bonus programs, and provides actionable data to improve operations and meet regulatory requirements.

Comprehensive fleet oversight

Cost Control Analyst

Samsara helps me keep track of my fleet vehicles and has helped us make informed decisions based on actionable data.

manager

We love using samsara , it makes our party rental company stress free, we know where our driver at all times, if they are speeding , maintenance  is easier with the app , it tell you what's wrong with vehicle, you don't have to keep track yourself .

93% of reviewers feel positive about Vehicle Tracking. Reviewers indicate that tracking vehicles, drivers, and assets in real time is essential for their business. Users say the system provides accurate location data, helps monitor driver behavior, and supports maintenance scheduling. They find value in features like route history, safety notifications, and the ability to track performance metrics. Many users mention that having reliable vehicle tracking improves peace of mind, operational efficiency, and compliance with regulations.

Intuitive and modern design

Direct of Safety and Compliance

Ease of use, user friendliness and most of the things are streamlined for efficiency and speed.

Lead Transportation Specialist

User friendly interface and plenty of online instruction through Samsara Acadamy.

93% of reviewers feel positive about the User Interface. Users think the interface is visually appealing, easy to navigate, and offers a streamlined experience. Reviewers appreciate that the design allows them to access information quickly and customize layouts to fit their needs. They say the intuitive structure helps new users get up to speed fast, and ongoing updates improve usability. Many users mention that the platform’s clarity and accessibility enhance operational control and reduce errors.

Operational visibility in real time

Business Owner

We like being able to see real time location of our fleet, also love the vehicle diagnostics. And it's very easy to recall video captures at certain moments of a trip for review.

Dispatcher

I like that we are able to share this live tracking, including what day & what time the link expires.

96% of reviewers feel positive about Real-Time Tracking. Users think the ability to monitor fleet locations instantly and access live data is crucial for operational efficiency. Reviewers appreciate features like GPS accuracy, live video integration, and event-based alerts, which help them validate incidents, manage assets, and make quick decisions. They say real-time tracking improves accountability, supports compliance, and streamlines daily tasks. Many reviewers indicate that sharing live tracking links with clients and accessing detailed analytics are valuable for customer service and internal audits.

The system automatically detects and uploads clips of harsh events or distracted driving, which makes coaching our drivers much easier and provides great insurance protection in case of accidents."

dispatcher

The GPS tracking is accurate, the dashboard gives good visibility into driver and vehicle activity, and the video features add an extra layer of accountability and safety.

Regional Director

The equipment is durable, fast, and provides audio minders to drivers when they are demonstrating negative behaviors (ex: looking at their cell phones, speeding, not wearing a seatbelt, etc.).

QC QA Auditor

Samsara has been an incredible asset to us for ensuring safety of our fleet on the road, reducing incidents with our drivers, providing support following an incident, and providing an avenue through which we can affirm, encourage, and reward our Enforcement officers for above average performance!  

Safety Director

Samsara ia a great product that provides for all my logging needs in one place, from quick access to driver logs and editing, to managing gayeways and vehicle locations.

Safety and Compliance Manager

The real-time GPS tracking is reliable, and having immediate visibility into vehicle locations, idling, speed, and driver behavior has significantly improved our operational oversight and accountability.

safety manager

I also want to mention the updates  the data connection is limited, and with weekly updates this often causes incorrect hour calculations for drivers. When it comes to hours, this is a real issue, especially because Samsara is considered one of the best ELD devices in the USA, and my company uses it mainly because the logs cannot be edited. Because of that, Samsara should improve its services and make things easier for drivers, not force them to do “math problems” just to guess how many hours they will have. And with constant updates, there’s always a risk that the logbook won’t work the way it should.

DIRECTOR OF FLEET MANAGEMENT

SOME OF THE SET UP COULD BE STREAMLINES, FOR INSTANCE I CREATED SERVICE INTERVALS FOR BASIC OIL CHANGES, EVERYTIME I NEED TO ADD A VEHICLE I NEED TO GO INTO THE SETTINGS AND MANUALLY PUT IT IN.

Admin Trainer Hours of Service Logs

TICKET turn around time is a HUGE issue for me. When I open a ticket, I am in need of a QUICK resolution b/c the majority of the time, the issues is affecting my drivers logs and they can't drive until it's corrected or fixed.

AI software to help make our drivers as safe as possible, also helps safety managers track events and help with customer satifaction.

National Asset Manager

I don't like the battery life on the AG-51 asset tracker when it comes to unpowered fleet assets that are on the road for extended periods of time as the batteries would die and would cause us to lose tracking on assets until batteries could be replaced.

The video system is also a big plus because it helps clear up incidents quickly and provides protection for both the company and the driver if something happens on the road.  

Since one of our primary functions with our operation is to enforce parking, our fleet and our large number of Enforcement Officers are vital to a successful operation.  

Manager

Video function and its easy to navigate when looking for the asset in our fleet also It makes tracking vehicles, reviewing information, and managing day to day operations simple and efficient.

Senior Claims adjuster

It simplifies day-to-day operations and gives a clear view of all vehicles in one place, which really reduces stress while managing the fleet

Admin

We also like that you can send real-time tracking to customers, and they can easily access and track the trucks.

Logistics Supervisor

the we could use this system for actually gps for truckers to be able to safely get from point a and point b via semi safe passage roads

Account Manager

The system also gives us helpful insight into driver behavior and maintenance needs, which has pushed us to stay ahead of service issues and coach safer driving habits, both of which have real financial benefits when you’re running a fleet.

Aggregate Dispatch Coordinator

This is a tool that allows us to more efficiently and accurately: bill customers, pay drivers, dispatch drivers, maintain equipment, track milage, address safety concerns and track driver's licenses and medical cards.

Fleet

The live tracking accuracy and camera footage help a lot during incidents, coaching, and operational monitoring.

Samsara vs MyTrucking Comparison (2026)

Samsara

MyTrucking

Overview

Video & Screenshots

Pricing

User reviews

Key features

Integrations

Alternatives