ShelbyNext Membership vs Tithe.ly

Planning Center

Pushpay

FellowshipOne

Subsplash

Givelify

Compare ShelbyNext Membership and Tithe.ly based on features, pricing, verified reviews, integrations & more on GetApp. Find out which software is best for your business in 2026.

Church management software by FellowshipOne is designed to assist churches and other related organizations with structuring and managing all aspects of daily operations, all in one cloud-based, integrated platform.

Planning Center is an all-in-one church management system made to help you organize information, coordinate events, communicate with your team, and connect with your congregation. 

Use different tools for your ministry needs while keeping everyone informed about what's happening around the church.

ACS is a church management software designed to help churches of all sizes handle finances, members, services, background checks, contributions, accounting processes, payroll, purchase orders, and more on a centralized platform.

ShelbyNext Membership offers attendance tracking, events scheduling and automating processes & workflows for churches and other non-profit organizations

Access Controls/Permissions

Accounting Integration

Attendance Tracking

Built-in Accounting

Child Check-in

Contact Database

Data Import/Export

Donation Management

Event Management

Event Scheduling

For Religious Organizations

Member Communication

Member Directory

Member Portal

Membership Management

Mobile Access

Mobile App

Multi-Location

Online Calendar

Online Giving

Pledge Management

Search/Filter

Small Group Management

Third-Party Integrations

Visitor Tracking

Volunteer Management

Website Management

Worship Planning

ShelbyNext Membership

Android

Web-based

iPad

iPhone

IT volunteer

The support has always been outstanding -- every individual I've worked with is friendly and super helpful. And the crowdsourced support (online) gets good answers to your questions too.

Disipleship Pastor

This is still a good software for the church wanting to connect with its members more frequently. We love the ability to track leadership encounters with our membership.

Finance Director

There is no alert given if there is a problem on a background check. There is no way to indicate family relationships such as grandmother, siblings, nieces, nephew, etc.

Membership Secretary

We previously used Shelby V.  Both products have a great deal of advantages in our congregational needs. ShelbyNext seems to be more user friendly that Shelby V.

Office Administrator

Robust functionality combined with security makes us look good and gives us peace-of-mind at the same time. Also, ShelbyNext listens to their user-base and continuously improves the product.

Ministry Assistant

We've had several instances where when problems arose, customer service reps were just as perplexed with the issue.

Accounting

It's a really solid product overall. The best features are it's ability to easily enter, edit, combine or delete member records.

Administrative Assistant & Membership Secretary

I love the ease of making workflows to send automatic emails. I also like the layout and user interface.

Outsourced Bookkeeper

No back arrow to look at the previous transaction entered. If you are entering a list of manual checks and need to add a vendor all of the previous info entered (date, check number etc) is lost.

Owner

The integration between Membership and Financials helps to reduce work and the common errors of entering data. I can't say enough, thank you all for doing such a great job.

I also like the way it helps to mainstream our ministry workflow, by providing a variety of tools that integrate between ministries and departments.

Lead Pastor

It’s fairly costly and takes a long time to get up and running. It’s broken into different windows.

Adult Group and Student Life Admin

The way a SMS message in Mass Contact does not send as a full message but instead delivers as several out-of-order text with words broken up in odd locations.

Administrative assistant

It also appears that they are still working out a lot of glitches and it’s very frustrating when you depend on a software and it doesn’t work properly at least 99% of the time.

Webmaster

Requires multiple logins, slow to implement new features, lags behind competition.

Accounting Specialist

Overall I am satisfied with ShelbyNext and the customer support is always available to assist us when we get in over our heads.

Children's Pastor

This software allows us to move through our multi-step financial approval process efficiently. It allows us to track expenses and budgets easily while providing detailed reporting features.

Child Checkin has been a nightmare getting the software to work with the printer. Also, mobile checkin for attendees is so cumbersome to use, no one will use it, especially our older folks.

ShelbyNext Membership screenshot: ShelbyNext - Aceess member directory on the go through mobile app

ShelbyNext Membership screenshot: ShelbyNext - Attendance managent by leaders or teachers through mobile app

ShelbyNext Membership screenshot: ShelbyNext - Individual profile of members

ShelbyNext Membership screenshot: ShelbyNext - Member check in through mobile app

ShelbyNext Membership screenshot: ShelbyNext - Mobile and web based access

ShelbyNext Membership screenshot: ShelbyNext - Record interactions with members through mobile app

Freelancers

Large Enterprises

Mid Size Business

Non Profit

Small Business

Pushpay is a digital giving and engagement platform designed to help churches manage processes related to donations and fundraising. It allows faith-based organizations to increase generosity and participation, engage with communities, and streamline financial workflows.

Subsplash is the leader in church apps that are built for discipleship and engagement. Subsplash apps are integrated with your Subsplash people database, giving, websites, live streaming, media library, events, and church management, giving everything you need to know, grow, and engage your church.

Givelify is a three-tap mobile giving & donation management platform for churches, nonprofits, fundraisers, and donors to make, process and record donations

Tithe.ly is a web & mobile based donation platform providing digital giving tools & event management features for ministries & churches of all sizes

ACH Payment Processing

Activity Dashboard

Activity Tracking

Ad hoc Reporting

Alerts/Notifications

Application Management

Attendance Management

Campaign Management

Campaign Planning

Cash Management

Check Printing

Collaboration Tools

Committee Management

Communication Management

Contact Management

Content Library

Content Management

Contribution Tracking

Credit Card Processing

Customer Database

Customizable Branding

Customizable Fields

Customizable Reports

Dashboard

Document Storage

Donation Tracking

Donor Management

Drag & Drop

Dues Management

Electronic Payments

Email Management

Email Marketing

Email Reminders

Email Templates

Enrollments/Onboarding

Event Calendar

Event Ticketing

For Nonprofits

Fund Accounting

Fundraising Management

General Ledger

Gift Matching Management

Goal Setting/Tracking

Grant Management

Image Editing

Image Library

Interaction Tracking

Media Library

Member Database

Member Types

Membership Renewals

Mobile Giving

Multi-Currency

Online Forms

Payment Processing

Personalization

Playlist Management

Presentation Streaming

Presentation Tools

Real-Time Notifications

Receipt Management

Recurring Giving

Recurring/Subscription Billing

Registration Management

Reminders

Reporting & Statistics

Reporting/Analytics

Role-Based Permissions

Scheduling

Self Service Portal

SMS Messaging

Social Media Integration

Summary Reports

Text Editing

Transaction History

Video Support

Tithe.ly

Windows

Pastor

Good resources for helping you navigate the website. Fun conferences and giveaways keep things interesting as well.

Executive Director

The negatives for Tithe.ly have to do with the lack of customization for their embedding iframe feature, as well as the lack of overall aesthetic for integration with preexisting websites.

Development Coordinator

I love that we have a customized app for our church. The push notifications are awesome.

They have always been the best bang for your buck, the most feature-rich platform, and bar none the best customer friendly staff around.

President

This tool is so great for both the Church and the member who is tithing. It's clean, easy to use and you can tell that a ton of investment went into the UI.

Websites are so important now for churches. We are just a recent addition to Tithe.ly and we are so far very happy.

Construction Manager

They provide multiple ways to give, great set up service, and you can literally be up and running in minutes. Integration into your website is a breeze and the app is easy and friendly to use.

Director of Media & Communications

Now it does because we launched Tithe.ly. It has been well received,  and the reports from our members have been overwhelmingly positive about how easy it is to use.

No report data in emails. Still get notifications of reports have no data, which is a waste of time, since you have to log in to see the report before you know there's no data.

I like the ease of use when people want to donate to my nonprofit.

Box Office Associate 

I loved that tithly was easy to use and assured me account security. It allowed me options like paying monthly, weekly or yearly.

Admin Assistant

You can designate what you are giving to several different categories if you want, and you can also set up automated giving. This has been a great investment for our church.

Teacher

The fact that it easily implemented with our WordPress website was a huge benefit and the major reason we decided to go with the company.

CEO, Administrator

It's extremely easy to integrate with my website, social media, and CRM. It's design is of such that it immediately built donar trust and increased large donations.

Emma.sikma@bcmedu.org

There are other options out there that are cheaper than this software. Would no longer be my first choice.

Executive Assistant

It just sounded too good to be true. But after researching and talking with their customer service reps I discovered it really is free.

Customizing was a bit difficult to figure out initially especially resizing our logo and getting the colors to match our branding.

Treasurer

Easy to access and get running. It is easy to get signed up and allow money to be given, but hard to get it from the company.

ShelbyNext Membership vs Tithe.ly Comparison (2026)

ShelbyNext Membership

Tithe.ly

Overview

Video & Screenshots

Pricing

User reviews

Key features

Integrations

Alternatives