Givebutter vs Cheddar Up

Zeffy

DonorPerfect

Donorbox

Zeffy is the first and only zero-free fundraising platform. Sell tickets for your fundraising events, create donation and peer-to-peer campaigns, and manage donors and even memberships from an intuitive all-inclusive fundraising platform.

DonorPerfect helps nonprofits of every size streamline fundraising and centralize donor data in one flexible, all-in-one platform.
A CRM that empowers teams to collaborate, stay organized, and make data-driven decisions from anywhere, so your mission keeps moving forward.

Donorbox is an embeddable, localized donation form / plugin for websites, designed to encourage recurring donations with fast, multi-step checkout

Project Manager

Should a resource ever not be available, their customer service is some of the best I have ever seen, with a human being able to answer my questions within minutes.

President

Customer service is amazing, they respond within minutes through the live chat and are very helpful.

Givebutter is a cloud-based, all-in-one fundraising platform for student organizations, sports teams, companies, and nonprofits which offers a range of tools for collecting donations online, running social peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns, selling tickets to fundraising events, and more

Access Controls/Permissions

Accounting

Accounting Integration

ACH Payment Processing

Activity Dashboard

Activity Tracking

Ad hoc Reporting

Alerts/Notifications

Alumni Management

Attendance Management

Auction Management

Bid Management

Billing & Invoicing

Buy Now Option

Campaign Analytics

Campaign Management

Campaign Planning

Campaign Segmentation

Communication Management

Contact Database

Contact Management

Contribution Tracking

Credit Card Processing

Customer Database

Customizable Branding

Customizable Fields

Customizable Forms

Customizable Reports

Customizable Templates

Dashboard

Data Import/Export

Document Storage

Donation Tracking

Donor Management

Dues Management

Electronic Payments

Email Management

Email Marketing

Email Reminders

Email Templates

Email Tracking

Event Management

Event Ticketing

Forms Management

For Nonprofits

Fundraising Management

Gift Matching Management

Goal Setting/Tracking

Image Library

Interaction Tracking

Inventory Management

Live Auction

Member Database

Membership Management

Mobile Access

Mobile Alerts

Mobile Giving

Online Auction

Online Bidding

Online Forms

Online Giving

Payment Processing

Personalization

Pledge Management

Real-Time Analytics

Real-Time Monitoring

Real-Time Notifications

Real-Time Reporting

Receipt Management

Recurring Giving

Recurring/Subscription Billing

Registration Management

Reminders

Reporting/Analytics

Reporting & Statistics

Search/Filter

Silent Auction

Social Media Integration

Summary Reports

Task Management

Third-Party Integrations

Volunteer Management

Watch List

Web Forms

Website Integration

Workflow Management

By industry, Givebutter reviewers are most commonly professionals in non-profit organization management (49%). The most frequent use case for Givebutter cited by reviewers is fundraising (76% of reviewers).

Users and use cases

Most users consider Givebutter to offer excellent value for money, especially for nonprofits, and they appreciate the free tier with essential features. However, some reviewers feel that processing and integration fees can become burdensome, especially if donors do not cover them.

Value for money

The Givebutter integrations most frequently cited by reviewers are: Stripe (a payment processing product rated 4.8 out of 5 for its integration with Givebutter), Bloomerang (a donation management product, 4.2), and Mailchimp (an email marketing product, 4.3).

Integrations

Givebutter is a fundraising program with key features that include donation tracking, credit card processing, electronic payments, campaign management, donor management, and more.

Open Source

Givebutter

Web-based

Bloomerang

OneCause

GoFundMe

GoFundMe Pro

GiveSmart

Bloomerang Fundraising

Little Green Light

Blackbaud Raiser's Edge NXT

Bonterra Network for Good

Neon CRM

Bonterra EveryAction

RallyUp

Givelify

Basic

Confusing and unwanted tipping feature

Program Director

I don't like that it is set to automatically include a tip for Givebutter and that donors have to uncheck that box to avoid adding a tip.

Volunteer

I dislike that it automatically wants the user to pay a tip to GiveButter and they have to manually uncheck the box.

69% of reviewers feel negative about Givebutter’s tipping model. Some users say the automatic inclusion of a tip during checkout confuses donors, especially older supporters, and can lead to accidental extra charges. Reviewers indicate that donors often overlook the option to opt out, resulting in frustration and requests for refunds. They find the tipping prompts detract from the donation experience and can be perceived as sneaky or excessive. Users think this feature negatively impacts donor satisfaction and trust.

Challenging transaction handling

Administrative Assistant

I don't like how to download transaction files, it is a two-step process.

Volunteer and Secretary

It was a bit difficult to figure out how to actually withdraw the money, especially with Stripe involved as well, but I used help articles and live chat for assistance.

51% of reviewers feel negative about Givebutter’s transaction management. Some users report difficulties with reconciling donation dates and deposit dates, causing accounting headaches. Reviewers indicate that the process for withdrawing funds and managing recurring payments can be confusing, especially with third-party integrations like Stripe. They find it hard to transfer transactions between campaigns, export transaction data efficiently, and correct donor errors without support. Users think these limitations add unnecessary complexity to financial management.

Frequent glitches and frustrations

Membership and Development Director

The biggest issue I had was importing all of our contact from our current CRM.

Director of Development

However there are so many glitches that come up.

58% of reviewers feel negative about Givebutter’s reliability due to bugs and issues. Some users report frequent glitches, slow uploads, and errors that disrupt their workflow. Reviewers mention challenges with importing contacts, incomplete CRM functionality, and occasional problems with platform updates. They find troubleshooting difficult, especially when support is not immediately available. Users think these technical issues create extra work and can make the platform feel unfinished or clunky at times.

Limited and cumbersome email tools

President of Foundation

Additionally, the Engage email platform is still pretty limited in formatting -- cannot "center justify" text or images as one minor example that makes a difference in aesthetics.

Contact management and email CRM is extremely hard to use

50% of reviewers feel negative about Givebutter’s email communication features. Some users report that the email platform lacks advanced formatting options and makes tasks like centering text or images difficult. Reviewers indicate that setting up email campaigns and managing contacts can be confusing and time-consuming. They find reporting on email engagement and handling unsubscribes or bounces challenging. Users think the system’s limitations force them to use external tools for mail merges and newsletters, adding extra steps to their workflow.

Quick and easy setup process

Administrative Director

It works well with our CRM system and is easy to set up and deploy.

Director

Ease of setup and deployment, and the UI is better than most.

98% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s setup process. Some users report that getting started with the platform is straightforward, with clear instructions and minimal technical barriers. Reviewers appreciate that they can quickly deploy campaigns and integrate with existing systems, such as CRMs. They find the onboarding experience smooth and value the platform’s user-friendly design, which allows even those with limited technical expertise to set up and launch fundraising initiatives rapidly. Users think the ease of setup helps them focus on their core mission.

Boosts fundraising outcomes

Co-Founder

This platform has helped us increase our credibility and fundraising efforts as a newer non-profit and we appreciate the customer service and free webinars to expand our knowledge and growth.

As a non-profit, we are tight with resources, time, and funds ...yet Givebutter provided a sophisticated, easy-to-use, inexpensive platform that helped us raise money for our cause (awarding scholarships to students pursuing journalism in their higher education journey.)

96% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s impact on fundraising success. Some users say the platform helps them reach and surpass fundraising goals, even with limited resources. Reviewers appreciate features that make it easy to organize events, engage supporters, and track individual and team progress. They find that the platform’s user-friendly design encourages participation and increases donor engagement. Users report that Givebutter’s affordability and effective tools have enabled them to raise significant funds for their causes, often exceeding previous results.

Tailored for small nonprofits

Operations Director

As a small nonprofit with only a few employees, Givebutter allows me to focus on my other tasks and not spend hours on the donor tools.

Artistic and Executive Director

I like that there isn't an annual fee, allowing our small nonprofit the ability to grow.

95% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s suitability for nonprofit organizations. Some users say the platform is particularly beneficial for small nonprofits with limited budgets, as it offers essential fundraising and donor management tools at little or no cost. Reviewers appreciate the absence of annual fees and the cost-effective pricing structure, which allows them to maximize funds for their mission. They find the platform’s features align well with the needs of growing or startup nonprofits, making it easier to manage campaigns and donor relationships efficiently.

Intuitive and simple platform

Founder and Executive Director

It is easy to use on the back end and front end.

Director and Doula

GiveButter's ease of use and straightforward format is what I like most about it.

96% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s ease of use. Some users say the platform is intuitive and requires little to no training, making it accessible for all staff and volunteers. Reviewers appreciate the clear layout and visually appealing interface, which helps them navigate tasks efficiently. They find it straightforward to set up campaigns, track contributions, and manage donor information. Users think the platform’s simplicity reduces onboarding time and makes daily operations less stressful. Many reviewers feel that even those with limited technical skills can use the software confidently and effectively.

Comprehensive fundraising tools

Member

Givebutter made it possible for us to have all of our fundraising endeavors (in-kind donations, ticket sales, auction, etc.) for our event in one place and was very intuitive for our users.

Development Coordinator

So far, Givebutter has streamlined our fundraising by having our CRM, campaign pages, and real-time donation tracking in one place.

97% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s fundraising capabilities. Some users report that the platform consolidates various fundraising activities—such as peer-to-peer campaigns, ticketing, auctions, and event management—into one intuitive system. Reviewers indicate that having all fundraising tools in one place saves time and streamlines operations. They value the customization options, real-time tracking, and integration with payment methods like Venmo and PayPal. Users think the platform’s collaborative features and transparent pricing make it a practical choice for diverse fundraising needs.

Executive Director

Very simple and effective to set up campaigns, embed in our website, collect funds, report on contributions, transfer to bank accounts.

Marketing Director

Also the ability to display top donors with tickets as well as donations.

Office Manager

In summary, Givebutter is a robust and user-friendly platform suitable for nonprofits seeking an integrated solution for fundraising and donor management. While it may not offer all the advanced features of more complex systems, its ease of use, comprehensive support, and transparent pricing make it a valuable tool for many organizations.

Director of Advancement

It also seamlessly connects all the pieces of fundraising together which includes the communications, marketing, auctions, event creation,  data collection etc.  

Board Member

Our critical mission, our achievements, our grant-getting power, our social media presence, and "Give Butter" as recording platform enabled us to buy our building just this past year.

Artistic Director

Just in our artistic specialization in New York, I estimate that $2 million per year of donations and ticket sales could be processed through Givebutter if it had those features. If any other company sent us automatic emails after someone made a donation or bought a ticket and had adequately professional forms, we would stop using Givebutter and switch services immediately.

Director, Events and Development

I think some customization features (e.g. customized thank you emails for each "ticket type") are missing, which hinders my specific priorities; however, Givebutter's roadmap and ability to upvote features have been great ways to share my wants.

Marketing and PR Manager

We use it for all our donations capabilities, including in-person and online events, ticketing, auctions, and fundraising campaigns.

Executive director

We experimented with rewording and even changed the donate button text to “Send Money Here,” but clearer options or customizable settings would have helped.

The ability to customize everything from colors, logos, links, QR codes, etc has been second to none!

Annual Giving and Events Manager

Our Communications Specialist shares that you cannot as easily aesthetically edit emails to make them visually captivating in the same way you can in other platforms like MailChimp or Constant Contact.

Treasurer

We have multiple fundraisers and they all transfer as “Givebutter”.   If we could make it say “Givebutter basketball” or even a few letters so the person doing bank reconciliation knows which of the 5 Givebutter sub accounts the transfer came from.  

The lack of ability to sell tickets through the app or for patrons to be able to select seats from a seating chart makes the "Event" function of Givebutter far less useful than it could be for us.

Account Manager

It’s perfect for teams, allowing for seamless collaboration. While there are a few areas for improvement, like more customization options, the support and features provided have been invaluable for our fundraising efforts.

So if you're already using a Stripe account you'll have to get ANOTHER Stripe Express account that doesn't include important information about your constituents you already have in Stripe, like their customer ID numbers, cc info and more.

Givebutter vs Cheddar Up Comparison (2026)

Givebutter

Cheddar Up

Overview

Video & Screenshots

Pricing

User reviews

Key features

Integrations

Alternatives