Givebutter vs Click & Pledge

Zeffy

DonorPerfect

Donorbox

Zeffy is the first and only zero-free fundraising platform. Sell tickets for your fundraising events, create donation and peer-to-peer campaigns, and manage donors and even memberships from an intuitive all-inclusive fundraising platform.

DonorPerfect helps nonprofits of every size streamline fundraising and centralize donor data in one flexible, all-in-one platform.
A CRM that empowers teams to collaborate, stay organized, and make data-driven decisions from anywhere, so your mission keeps moving forward.

Donorbox is an embeddable, localized donation form / plugin for websites, designed to encourage recurring donations with fast, multi-step checkout

Project Manager

Should a resource ever not be available, their customer service is some of the best I have ever seen, with a human being able to answer my questions within minutes.

Director of Development

The software is intuitive and robust and the best of all that is possible with Givebutter is the absolute world class customer service.

Givebutter is a cloud-based, all-in-one fundraising platform for student organizations, sports teams, companies, and nonprofits which offers a range of tools for collecting donations online, running social peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns, selling tickets to fundraising events, and more

Access Controls/Permissions

Accounting

Accounting Integration

ACH Payment Processing

Activity Dashboard

Activity Tracking

Ad hoc Reporting

Alerts/Notifications

Alumni Management

Attendance Management

Auction Management

Bid Management

Billing & Invoicing

Buy Now Option

Campaign Analytics

Campaign Management

Campaign Planning

Campaign Segmentation

Communication Management

Contact Database

Contact Management

Contribution Tracking

Credit Card Processing

Customer Database

Customizable Branding

Customizable Fields

Customizable Forms

Customizable Reports

Customizable Templates

Dashboard

Data Import/Export

Document Storage

Donation Tracking

Donor Management

Dues Management

Electronic Payments

Email Management

Email Marketing

Email Reminders

Email Templates

Email Tracking

Event Management

Event Ticketing

Forms Management

For Nonprofits

Fundraising Management

Gift Matching Management

Goal Setting/Tracking

Image Library

Interaction Tracking

Inventory Management

Live Auction

Member Database

Membership Management

Mobile Access

Mobile Alerts

Mobile Giving

Online Auction

Online Bidding

Online Forms

Online Giving

Payment Processing

Personalization

Pledge Management

Real-Time Analytics

Real-Time Monitoring

Real-Time Notifications

Real-Time Reporting

Receipt Management

Recurring Giving

Recurring/Subscription Billing

Registration Management

Reminders

Reporting/Analytics

Reporting & Statistics

Search/Filter

Silent Auction

Social Media Integration

Summary Reports

Task Management

Third-Party Integrations

Volunteer Management

Watch List

Web Forms

Website Integration

Workflow Management

By industry, Givebutter reviewers are most commonly professionals in non-profit organization management (49%). The most frequent use case for Givebutter cited by reviewers is fundraising (76% of reviewers).

Users and use cases

Most users consider Givebutter to offer excellent value for money, especially for nonprofits, and they appreciate the free tier with essential features. However, some reviewers feel that processing and integration fees can become burdensome, especially if donors do not cover them.

Value for money

The Givebutter integrations most frequently cited by reviewers are: Stripe (a payment processing product rated 4.8 out of 5 for its integration with Givebutter), Bloomerang (a donation management product, 4.2), and Mailchimp (an email marketing product, 4.3).

Integrations

Givebutter is a fundraising program with key features that include donation tracking, credit card processing, electronic payments, campaign management, donor management, and more.

Open Source

Givebutter

Web-based

Bloomerang

OneCause

GoFundMe

GoFundMe Pro

GiveSmart

Bloomerang Fundraising

Little Green Light

Blackbaud Raiser's Edge NXT

Bonterra Network for Good

Neon CRM

Bonterra EveryAction

RallyUp

Givelify

Basic

Confusing automatic tipping

Program Director

I don't like that it is set to automatically include a tip for Givebutter and that donors have to uncheck that box to avoid adding a tip.

Coordinator

You can't customize certain features and the tipping is frustrating for major donors, don't recommend for larger donations

70% of reviewers feel negative about Givebutter’s tipping feature. Users report that the automatic inclusion of a tip during checkout confuses donors, with many not noticing the default tip or struggling to remove it. Reviewers indicate that this process frustrates major donors and older audiences, sometimes leading to accidental tips and refund requests. Some users say the tipping model detracts from the donor experience, causing confusion and dissatisfaction during transactions. They find the tip amounts to be unexpectedly high and difficult to track.

Complex transaction handling

So if you're already using a Stripe account you'll have to get ANOTHER Stripe Express account that doesn't include important information about your constituents you already have in Stripe, like their customer ID numbers, cc info and more.

Volunteer and Secretary

It was a bit difficult to figure out how to actually withdraw the money, especially with Stripe involved as well, but I used help articles and live chat for assistance.

51% of reviewers feel negative about Givebutter’s transaction management. Users report difficulties with payment processing, withdrawal procedures, and syncing transaction dates with accounting records. Reviewers indicate that managing RSVPs, transferring transactions between campaigns, and handling recurring payments are cumbersome. Some users say the integration with third-party payment systems like Stripe adds complexity, and they struggle to correct donor errors or export transaction notes easily. They find these challenges lead to manual workarounds and confusion for both staff and donors.

Frequent glitches and frustrations

Office Manager

Contacts being only individuals and not businesses, with no mode of addressing couples makes letter composition in GB impossible for us.

Membership and Development Director

The biggest issue I had was importing all of our contact from our current CRM.

59% of reviewers feel negative about Givebutter’s bugs and technical issues. Users report recurring glitches, slow uploads, and difficulties with importing contacts or integrating with other platforms. Reviewers indicate that the CRM side lacks flexibility, especially for business contacts, and some find the UI clunky and confusing. Some users say troubleshooting is challenging due to limited support and ongoing updates. They mention that these technical frustrations create extra work and hinder smooth operation, especially during critical fundraising events.

Limited and complicated email tools

Administrative Coordinator

The only challenge I've encountered has been a somewhat limited platform for newsletters- especially when trying to seek diverse avenues to recruit new readers.

President of Foundation

Additionally, the Engage email platform is still pretty limited in formatting -- cannot "center justify" text or images as one minor example that makes a difference in aesthetics.

49% of reviewers feel negative about Givebutter’s email communication features. Users report that the email platform is limited in formatting options and difficult to set up for newsletters or donor outreach. Reviewers indicate that managing custom emails, handling bounced addresses, and implementing multiple admins for notifications are problematic. Some users say reporting and contact management are confusing, and they receive too many emails from the platform. They find the email tools less effective compared to other solutions, requiring extra effort for communication tasks.

Quick and simple setup

Executive Director and VOLUNTEER

it's easy to set up, easy to share across multiple platforms, and easy to check out.

Director

Ease of setup and deployment, and the UI is better than most.

98% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s setup process. Users indicate that setting up the platform is straightforward and fast, with many saying they could deploy it with minimal effort. Reviewers appreciate the clear documentation and user-friendly interface, which makes onboarding easy for both individuals and organizations. Some users report that the setup works well across multiple platforms and integrates smoothly with other systems. They find the initial account creation and fundraiser setup intuitive, allowing them to start fundraising quickly without technical barriers or lengthy tutorials.

Effective fundraising outcomes

Executive Director

Givebutter's cool live fundraising tools are what drew me in. When I watched a fellow nonprofit owner raise $15k in at 15 minutes using a projection of Givebutter's live giving tool, I knew I had to try it.

President

As a non-profit, we are tight with resources, time, and funds ...yet Givebutter provided a sophisticated, easy-to-use, inexpensive platform that helped us raise money for our cause (awarding scholarships to students pursuing journalism in their higher education journey.)

96% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s fundraising success. Users report that the platform helps them reach their fundraising goals, often exceeding expectations. Reviewers appreciate the ease of tracking funds raised and the ability to organize events that generate substantial support. Some users say the platform’s intuitive tools and low fees contribute to their ability to raise more money. They find that Givebutter enables both small and large organizations to maximize impact, making fundraising accessible and efficient.

Tailored for small nonprofits

Operations Director

As a small nonprofit with only a few employees, Givebutter allows me to focus on my other tasks and not spend hours on the donor tools.

Artistic and Executive Director

I like that there isn't an annual fee, allowing our small nonprofit the ability to grow.

96% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s suitability for nonprofits. Users think the platform is ideal for small organizations with limited budgets, citing its cost-effectiveness and free implementation. Reviewers appreciate features that help them manage donor relations, fundraising, and CRM without high fees. Some users report that Givebutter’s accessible tools and resources enable them to focus on critical tasks and grow their organizations. They value the platform’s commitment to serving nonprofits and its ability to integrate with other systems.

Intuitive user experience

Director and Doula

GiveButter's ease of use and straightforward format is what I like most about it.

Vice President

96% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s ease of use. Users find the platform intuitive and visually appealing, with a clean interface that simplifies navigation. Reviewers appreciate that even non-technical staff can use it without extra training. Some users say the platform’s tutorials and clear instructions make learning easy. They indicate that the user-friendly design allows for quick setup, easy sharing, and seamless donor engagement, making their fundraising efforts more efficient and enjoyable.

Comprehensive fundraising tools

Member

Givebutter made it possible for us to have all of our fundraising endeavors (in-kind donations, ticket sales, auction, etc.) for our event in one place and was very intuitive for our users.

97% of reviewers feel positive about Givebutter’s fundraising capabilities. Users think the platform offers a wide range of tools, including peer-to-peer fundraising, ticketing, personalized pages, and event management. Reviewers appreciate being able to manage all fundraising activities in one place, which saves time and resources. Some users say the platform’s cost-effectiveness and donor engagement features are valuable for small nonprofits. They find that the ability to customize campaigns and track donations helps streamline their fundraising efforts and increases donor participation.

Very simple and effective to set up campaigns, embed in our website, collect funds, report on contributions, transfer to bank accounts.

In summary, Givebutter is a robust and user-friendly platform suitable for nonprofits seeking an integrated solution for fundraising and donor management. While it may not offer all the advanced features of more complex systems, its ease of use, comprehensive support, and transparent pricing make it a valuable tool for many organizations.

Director of Advancement

It also seamlessly connects all the pieces of fundraising together which includes the communications, marketing, auctions, event creation,  data collection etc.  

Board Member

Our critical mission, our achievements, our grant-getting power, our social media presence, and "Give Butter" as recording platform enabled us to buy our building just this past year.

Co-Founder

This platform has helped us increase our credibility and fundraising efforts as a newer non-profit and we appreciate the customer service and free webinars to expand our knowledge and growth.

Director, Events and Development

I think some customization features (e.g. customized thank you emails for each "ticket type") are missing, which hinders my specific priorities; however, Givebutter's roadmap and ability to upvote features have been great ways to share my wants.

Marketing and PR Manager

We use it for all our donations capabilities, including in-person and online events, ticketing, auctions, and fundraising campaigns.

Executive director

We experimented with rewording and even changed the donate button text to “Send Money Here,” but clearer options or customizable settings would have helped.

The ability to customize everything from colors, logos, links, QR codes, etc has been second to none!

Annual Giving and Events Manager

Our Communications Specialist shares that you cannot as easily aesthetically edit emails to make them visually captivating in the same way you can in other platforms like MailChimp or Constant Contact.

Treasurer

We have multiple fundraisers and they all transfer as “Givebutter”.   If we could make it say “Givebutter basketball” or even a few letters so the person doing bank reconciliation knows which of the 5 Givebutter sub accounts the transfer came from.  

Development Coordinator

So far, Givebutter has streamlined our fundraising by having our CRM, campaign pages, and real-time donation tracking in one place.

Account Manager

It’s perfect for teams, allowing for seamless collaboration. While there are a few areas for improvement, like more customization options, the support and features provided have been invaluable for our fundraising efforts.

We chose givebutter for several reasons but one of my favorite things is that we could see how much each team member was achieving with donations. Since we were two relay teams, the competition was fierce and givebutter helped us stay motivated and interested in fundraising!

That means generating a report and cleaning it up, then doing a mail merge, and then going in and manually selecting who has been acknowledged.

Senior Marketing Communications Specialist

We've enjoyed having more modern and holistic software that helps us raise funds for our day-to-day work and organize our events with the bonus of raising passive funds.

Program and Process Manager

Givebutter gives their customers a [significant] voice when it comes to product development and features, and they give customers direct visibility into their plans and roadmap.

Givebutter vs Click & Pledge Comparison (2026)

Givebutter

Click & Pledge

Overview

Video & Screenshots

Pricing

User reviews

Key features

Integrations

Alternatives