Butter Payments - 2026 Pricing, Features, Reviews & Alternatives

Butter’s Machine Learning Recovery tool converts failed payments from revenue losses into growth opportunities. Our system recovers lost revenue and enhances payment health by addressing the root causes behind payment failures.

How do we do it?

We build and deploy custom machine learning algorithms that analyze each individual failed payment, enabling us to determine the optimal approach and timing for retrying the transaction. Unlike traditional retry solutions that employ a generic "one-size-fits-all" approach, our tailored approach ensures that no potential recovered revenue is left on the table.

How do we work?

We integrate with major payment processors, subscription management platforms, and custom in-house systems. In addition, we operate under the highest security standards, including regular penetration testing, vulnerability assessments, and compliance certifications like SOC 2 Type 2 and PCI DSS Level 2.

We see you as our partner, where your success is our success. As such, we work under a revenue sharing agreement where we only make money on revenue we recovered.

To get started Butter’s payment experts—with a proven track record of success for Microsoft, Dropbox, Scribd, Curology—review a full year of your payment data to help you understand why your payments are failing and how much revenue you could be recovering. (Normally an analysis of this type would cost $10-20k with a consultant but at Butter it’s just part of our process.)

Give us a try! Intelligently tackling failed payments and payment health not only increased revenue recovered but also leads to:

- Reduced Churn Rates - Reducing customers lost to failed payments decreases churn – and the impacts compound over time

- Increased LTV:CAC Ratio - With fewer customers churning due to failed payments, your overall LTV improves.

- Increased Top-line ARR - More revenue recovered from failed payments leads to 5%-10% more revenue for the business.

Our clients include Fabletics, The Athletic, Dialpad, Dr. Squatch, Athena Club, Savage X Fenty, Found, Wyze Labs, airSlate, Tonal, JustFab, Hairstory, Eucalyptus, UrbanSitter, Simple, Bloom, Perlego, MuseScore, KitUp, Speechify, and more.