App comparison
Add up to 4 apps below to see how they compare. You can also use the "Compare" buttons while browsing.
FellowshipOne
Simple and integrated cloud-based church management software
(1)
GetApp offers objective, independent research and verified user reviews. We may earn a referral fee when you visit a vendor through our links.
Our commitment
Independent research methodology
Our researchers use a mix of verified reviews, independent research, and objective methodologies to bring you selection and ranking information you can trust. While we may earn a referral fee when you visit a provider through our links or speak to an advisor, this has no influence on our research or methodology.
How GetApp verifies reviews
GetApp carefully verified over 2 million reviews to bring you authentic software experiences from real users. Our human moderators verify that reviewers are real people and that reviews are authentic. They use leading tech to analyze text quality and to detect plagiarism and generative AI.
How GetApp ensures transparency
GetApp lists all providers across its website—not just those that pay us—so that users can make informed purchase decisions. GetApp is free for users. Software providers pay us for sponsored profiles to receive web traffic and sales opportunities. Sponsored profiles include a link-out icon that takes users to the provider’s website.
Rating criteria
Reviews by rating
Planning Center
Tithe.ly
Chmeetings
Recommended
Amy M.
Business Manager
Education Management, 1-10 employees
Review source
Transcript
Amy: My name is Amy. I'm a virtual executive assistant and I work for churches, and I give FellowshipOne...
Verified reviewer
Religious Institutions, 201-500 employees
Used daily for 1-2 years
Review source
Share this review:
It worked as a minimal tool, but never met expectations for what we needed as an org.
I've worked with resource management software before and this works as a way to manage data in a simple, easy-to-understand manner.
This software is intended to track information and data, but lacks any user friendly option including the ability to mass-upload your data.
Christiana F.
Nonprofit Organization Management, 11-50 employees
Used daily for 1-2 years
Review source
Share this review:
As someone who participated in every demo presentation and helped customize F1 to our needs, I understood and could easily use/manage F1. However, a main reason we wanted to implement this software was to get team leaders and members connected to it as well, which is where the difficulty came in. Unless you're a very frequent user, F1 is difficult to navigate and therefore did not help us accomplish our goal of having many people interacting with it.
When working with larger quantities of groups or peoples, you were able to apply a mass action which saved a lot of time. The authorization settings were customizable from person to person which was helpful for our pastors, leaders and staff.
The amount of functionalities the system had sometimes felt like too many and yet it was still difficult finding what you need. The language throughout the software isn't easily understandable unless you were in the setup demos.
Kim S.
Religious Institutions, 11-50 employees
Used daily for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
Overall, we have been pleased with member tracking, volunteer assignments, and groups created. Customer Service is most often quick to respond.
It is fairly customizable in regards to fields available. And, has a great report library.
Even though there are a vast number of Core reports that can be customizable, it is oftentimes difficult to get the exact information that is needed on a report. And difficult to troubleshoot when you create a report that seems to pull no data at all.
Verified reviewer
Printing, 51-200 employees
Used monthly for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
FellowshipOne has definitely been helpful in managing the ins and outs of our church overall, and makes the financial side of things very easy. Definitely has room to improve though.
FellowshipOne is great church management software; it helps you manage volunteers, tithing, kids ministry, background checks, and more. But it could definitely be more user-friendly and I wish they were better about offering new and improved features (for example, they came out with a free personalized church app last year, but it was pretty wonky and their customer support was shabby in supporting it. Felt like they just wanted to put something out there and hope nobody actually tried to use it.)
Again, not very user-friendly, hard to do simple things like change usernames/reset passwords, expensive, and not a ton of different features.
david t.
Nonprofit Organization Management, 11-50 employees
Used daily for 1-2 years
Review source
Share this review:
The software is very dynamic in what it can do. There isn't a system out there that has the reporting capabilities of FellowshipOne.
With any Enterprise software solution, you need to invest in training and learning the system. I do wish some areas were a little more intuitive but it appears F1 is fixing it with some of their 'F1 Assist' features.
Verified reviewer
Nonprofit Organization Management, 11-50 employees
Used daily for 1-2 years
Review source
Share this review:
The real best database size is nice. Also the pricing for specific tears was something we found beneficial as we were not a mega church
The integration with the other software is has been a bit challenging. It has also not been super user-friendly for the processes we’ve wanted to use it for. We would love to see a much more user-friendly interface when it comes to event registration, sign-ups and things like that. Also a more functional iPad option would be good
Amy S.
Religious Institutions, 51-200 employees
Used daily for 1-2 years
Review source
Share this review:
While it seems to have a lot of potential and it sounded great when they sold us our subscription, using the system has been frustrating and difficult on many levels. Helpful and kind customer service is available, but too much of it is required to make it effective.
It is fairly easy to add people (members/profiles) into the system, which is the driving force of the program.
It's a clunky, hard to understand system once you get past the initial member profile input. The reports are a BEAST to format and run, and sometimes they seem impossible.
Verified reviewer
Religious Institutions, 51-200 employees
Used daily for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
F1 beginning as a strong cloud solution and as packed with features. The good news is they haven't lost any of those features.
The bad news is they have stopped developing the core of their product for about 10 years. They are far behind competitors in the technology space and focus more on add-ons, not the day-to-day ministry tasks.
Johann S.
Nonprofit Organization Management, 501-1,000 employees
Used other for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
Absolutely nothing.
There is nothing good about this product or organization. Really bad service, support and logistics. Stay away.
This is a terrible product with some of the worst customer service in existence. The product is clunky and overly complicated. It is counter to what a real CRM should be. From sales to customer service, the experience with F1 and ministry brands is bad. You are constantly having to pursue them and their staff is rude. Look at Hubspot or Planning Center for a better experience.
Verified reviewer
Used weekly for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
made church member management so much easier!
Great database with lots of features to help keep up with church members, families,giving, etc. Probably the best of its kind!
You will need lots of training on how to efficiently use this program. It does sometimes do things that don't make sense. But thankfully there customer service reps are very knowledgeable and helpful. If you aren't super techy, this program might be a little challenging.
Amy C.
Nonprofit Organization Management, 11-50 employees
Used daily for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
One place to store all of our information that is necessary for manage a church.
Large database that can hold all the information you need about a church member. I like the features that let you add information about a member that can be specific. Also the important aspect of giving different people access to different portions of the system. Not everyone needs to see the financial information so that can be controlled by the rights you give each user. You can also control who can edit or add information. The phone app is useful but only give basic information.
Phone App would be more helpful if more information was available on a member. The report section is very tricky and difficult to use. I have had to call customer service on several occasions for help with setting up a report. On the plus side the customer service reps are helpful.
CK K.
Religious Institutions, 11-50 employees
Used daily for less than 6 months
Review source
Share this review:
We don’t even know where to start to describe our massive disappointment with this product. From poor customer service, useless training, horrific report system, sales person persuaded to upgrade to iOS hardware, when their app is still being developed.... there’s not one Sunday that our check in line works smoothly. Their solution? No solution. We regret we did not read these comments before signing that agreement. We are writing in here in hopes to prevent some one else make the same mistake.
No pros were added to this review
- Reports: unfriendly, useless fields - Service: no follow up, there’s never a solution, just apologizes.... - check in app: forced to use Bluetooth, still on testing mode... we have 10 devices we invested that simply do not work. - database: unfriendly to use - forms: very basic, unfriendly to use - Add On: literally most that you get included into any other software, in FO it’s an add on, which they only tell you afterwards.... Had to pay for ONE user to train on how to enhance reporting options. - Giving Platform: unfriendly, no comment line
Ana J.
Used daily for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
After exploring other databases, I appreciate the user friendliness of Fellowship One. The user face was easy to read and navigate.
Fellowship One served us well for many years, but were not able to take us to the level we needed out of our database. Over the last two years, several large issues came up that never seemed to be resolved by management and caused us to move to another database.
Verified reviewer
Used daily for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
What I used to like about Fellowship One was that it was the central hub for all data for the church organization.
What I have come to not like about Fellowship One is that after a number of mergers and acquisitions the software is no longer fully supported as it once was. It's cumbersome to use and even harder to modify to fit our needs. We have since gone elsewhere for FMS.
Matthew B.
Used weekly for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
It is a good searchable database for people in our church. And does have a multifunctional element to it for emailing and tracking. There are some things that can be trained on better to improve user use.
In emails you can only put on one attachment and it has to be under 1 mb. The first couple years it did not work on iPads or tablet templates. And it overall still has a late 90s early 2000s look.
Rob H.
Nonprofit Organization Management, 51-200 employees
Used weekly for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
Handles our church membership, small groups, event registration and giving needs
Improved their stability with Data Center upgrade. Mobile app development. Handles financial giving and event registrations. Manages small groups. Modular based.
Too many layers with multiple screens when adding new families. Label printing options too limited. Needs better customization of input screens, reporting and troubleshooting steps (printing). Would be great if you could send Factory Reset codes directly from the app based on the printer you're using. Would be great to make this client-less and webrtc.
Dan W.
Used daily for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
It keeps track of info for us.
It's better than nothing. I appreciate being able to see a person or household quickly but find that the at-a-glance value is very low.
Does not facilitate discipleship in this century. You need an updated UI/UX. F1 would greatly benefit from automated assimilation processes, etc.
Whitney S.
Religious Institutions, 1-10 employees
Used daily for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
This company started out great and has gone downhill. In the past year, we spent months trying to get a response from the billing department on an issue. The woman who was assigned to our company did not respond in a timely manner and, when she did respond, gave us wrong information or did not answer the initial question. We even purchased wrong equipment because we were misinformed about what we needed....
The software is helpful and you can run reports from your database for many different needs. Check-in works well.
Customer support and especially the billing department caused us many problems. The software is expensive and the contract will nickel & dime you if you try to leave early. The software is expansive and a lot of setup & upkeep has to be done manually.
Frank G.
Religious Institutions, 201-500 employees
Used daily for 2+ years
Review source
Share this review:
We used F1 for about 10 years. It's a great out of the box ChMS system that has a ton of different functionality. They will send a team out to help you implement the system, and they have built in support (the timeliness of resolution does leave something to be desired) and it really does do the majority of things a church would have a need to do. The downside for us was the lack of flexibility that some of the features had, and the lack of new features being released in a timely manner. The company has gone through a lot of change in the past few years, which has left a lot of customers feeling unsupported. While I would recommend a church taking a good look at F1, especially if they need something that can just be configured and run with, we decided to switch to a different system.
Out of the box solution that includes most every feature a church would need, including support.
Support hasn't been great, multiple changes in company ownership has left things feeling unstable.
Holly R.
Religious Institutions,
Review source
Share this review:
I can get reports that give me what I need to know and can manipulate those for just the information I need. I also really like the giving module - with the batch scanner - really fast, intuitive, and easy to administer. We aren't there yet, but when we are it will be easy to segregate check scanning from posting. I can also say that each time they make upgrades to the program, I am impressed with the improvements. It seems like F1 "gets it".
It is difficult to figure out how to enter a ticket to receive support. I wish they would streamline this process.
Dennis C.
Review source
Share this review:
I would recommend F1 but with high caution. Make sure you have a point person that is highly computer literate. Be very patient... I gave 5 stars to "Meets our needs" on the premise that eventually when we get all our questions answered - it will meet our needs. That's why we chose F1.
This software is very feature rich and capable. It has resolved some of our immediate needs with check-in for kids, contributions, and mobile app for access to our data base as well as our small groups. When you read my cons please don't think I would not choose F1 again. I am just highly displeased with how they set expectations and how they train.
They do a very poor job of setting expectations. While the system is capable of a lot of features...good luck figuring them out. They are very limiting on what they will show you during implementation of the product. We also paid for the certification training and even that is limited to what information they will release to you. It seems that their attitude is "You need to figure it out". They...
Natalie J.
Review source
Share this review:
I definitely recommend Fellowship One to other churches. It can help you manage your communications, volunteers, are various ministries in one unified software. The Fellowship Tech staff are quick to respond to issues and provide excellent training.
With the variety of features offered, Fellowship One provides our church with a unified way of communicating to our church attenders and implementing programs with efficiency. It also provides easy integration of volunteers into administrative capacities. The check-in feature that is offered with it is unmatched in it's ability to help churches provide safety for our littlest members while at the same time track ministry effectiveness.
Fellowship One is a bit of a learning curve. There are complicated steps to creating forms, activities, etc. that, for a small church staff, can seem overwhelming. It can also be hard to get buy-in from some of the staff members because of the lack of ease of use. Would love to see improvement in this area. However, Fellowship One provides excellent training opportunities to help get users up to speed on the software.
J. Scott A.
Review source
Share this review:
As things stand right now with what is available today, if your church is looking for a very good, if not great, Church Management System Fellowship One is the system you want. The old adage, "You get what you pay for" applies with a SaaS product you are no longer supporting a server and software yourself or trying to develop something on your own. Having said that the company's "development to production agility" needs improvement as there are still things that need to be done on the congregation facing side of this system that hopefully will be taken care of in the very near future and make F1 one of the most complete systems available.
Excellent implementation team! F1 software has delivered what they said it could deliver in response to our RFP. Support is responsive. Communication has been good. We have the benefit of many Active Network/Fellowship Tech employees attending and in membership at The Village. No server or site to manage is great (obviously that is a big part of what we pay for) Functionality is really good. Access to the data via API is great and getting better with every new API realm.
Implementation Team could have been more assertive with some suggestions and less with others. Though F1 has delivered it has not delivered at the level we had hoped for, specifically public facing via weblink where the UX has left a lot to be desired. The back-end functionality is great but the interface needs a makeover now. Support though responsive has been dismissive with some of our requests and we have experienced some delays on what we consider a pretty serious request.
Katie S.
Review source
Share this review:
Before we began using Fellowship One, our church was comprised of many data silos. These silos were formed due to the inaccuracy and difficulty of use of our previous system. Fellowship One offered us a wonderful tool that was easy for our staff to use, and allowed us to break down the silos and put our data all in one area. Event Registrations and Check-In are utilized heavily here at CSPC. Through my discussions with other churches, this system is great for all sizes - from the start-up church plants to mega size churches. Fellowship One is a wonderful tool that helps churches do ministry better! The only true limitation of this system is in the users of the system or how a church utilizes it for their ministries.
-Much more than just a database -Electronic check-in for any activity & secure check-in for children's events -Email communication to anyone or any group in system -Online registrations and online giving that ties to database records -Ability to tag records to allow for easy searches later (spiritual gifts, first time visitors, etc.) -Member portal (InFellowship) offers online church directory,...
-Contributions module lacking in area of audit trail (this is on their radar) -Reports sometimes hard to find due to size of report library. This issue is being handled with the creation of core reports that combine numerous reports into one all-encompassing report.
Debbie D.
Review source
Share this review:
I have seen tremendous growth and improvement in Fellowship One over the past 4 years. The staff at Fellowship Tech are extremely hardworking and committed to meeting the needs of churches. Many go above and beyond and that is the "heart" of FT. I am excited about what is yet to come!
*The trainings are easy to understand and can be viewed over and over *Addition of Best Practices and examples of processes is very helpful. Less of a learning curve when you have the benefit of other's experience. *We can see who's attending (or no longer attending), who's serving, who's giving and how (if) they're growing spiritually. *We can provide necessary follow-up care for our congregants...
*Finding reports takes time *Merging duplicates from new accounts is tedious & takes many steps to complete. *Would like to see more advanced trainings available online (i.e.: Adv activity set-up) *I wasn't here for the implementation (2005) and have rated the implementation review based on staff feedback. The process has changed since then and I'm sure has improved but I'm giving honest feedback based on our experience. *Ease-of-use is getting better but we would like F1 to be more intuitive especially for the non-tech pastors. *F1 is not integrated with Planning Center and our worship team info is not consistently up-to-date.